Adam and Heather Hayes

Life in small town U.S.A.

Why Math is Always Fun

January 17, 2008 by Adam

I've always liked math, and so I thought I'd share a little problem with you.

The following problem seems to follow all "normal" math rules. However,  it shows how if we are not careful, we can let what was 1=1 become 2=1. First let x= y = 1. 

  1. x  =  y
  2. x2  =  xy
  3. x2 - y=  xy - y2
  4. (x + y)(x - y)  =  y(x - y)
  5. x + y = y
  6. 2 = 1

Now I don't want you to pull your kid out of their math class because all of a sudden math is lying to you. There is a perfectly logical reason this "proof" doesn't work. 

For you out there that are scratching your heads, don't worry, you are in good company. The problem lies in step 5 where they have divided by (x-y) to get what you have remaining in step 5. However, this is the reason you CAN'T DIVIDE BY 0. It just messes things up. (How was that for a technical response.)

Your Comments
  • kara made this comment on January 19, 2008
    Is it any surprise that I was lost before I got through the directions? Maybe I should have spent more time listening to Mrs. Gray and less time trying to sneak my assignments in done in pen!
 
 
Add Your Own Comment